Why Manchester United must still sack Erik ten Hag despite 'greatest performance of post-Fergie era'

The FA Mug final was proof of why Manchester United should both retain and sack Erik 10 Hag. Arsenal supporters are obscure why they’re being dragged in.

Send your pointers to [email protected].

Marching in
What a sweet race it was for attention in the Championship this year, coating in Sunday’s enjoyable — and tight — tinker-off final.

After remarking Leicester steal Saints to chunks at St Mary’s last Loss, I was intelligently particular the Foxes would be snagging one of the automated attention locations, but was escaped far from hesitant around Russell Martin’s household-to-the-max ideology, an methodology that appeared to be also unthinking to teams messing around without arrest on the reprieve. After the long unbeaten spell, I was appreciative to be substantiated notorious, and I was cheerfully startled by the critical versatility Martin showed in the final by organizing to tinker a extensively polymorphous methodology against Leeds (that were unlucky to come away empty handed from the season after accruing so numerous points).

It will most clearly be impressive to see if Russell Martin evolves his footballing ideology once encountered wearing the confound of the optimal tier.
Remy the Saint

Arsenal’s suitability
I was let down wearing Arsenal’s suitability on Saturday. I fingered we possessed a genuinely sweet season, but we make it feasible for ourselves down on Saturday. After the sweet rushed we possessed (16 wins in 18 suits), to run out the season assistance that on Saturday was unsuitable.

What? Arsenal didn’t tinker? Then why on earth were there two emails denigrating us, and pretending as yet that possessed any bearing whatsoever on our season? I below-par, I become aware it is two of the public transgressors, but you don’t have to publish them.

I recover why humans were appreciative Metropolis won the league, I would have been the super same if any of our rivals were against them in a title race. Arsenal capitivating would below-par something. Yet United capitivating the cup has most clearly no bearing on Arsenal whatsoever.
Jaimie Kaffash, AFC, north London

The ideata that United possessed a much more detailed season than Arsenal single makes sensation within the context of what each nightclub is premeditating to make application and the standards being calculated. Correct currently the perfunctory at United is of a exceptionally mid-table smorgasbord so I can see how their supporters think they possessed a much more detailed season than Arsenal by capitivating the FA cup. Apparently, this is currently how we should structure things once we’re chatting around Manchester United Football Bar.

Prefer any mid-table side, they possessed most clearly no likelihood of capitivating the league this season. If your topmost pep is gone away to ripping off a marginal trophy against a Metropolis team vividly still grasp up against the chattel of their brief message-weekend break revelry as upbraided to genuinely capitivating the league after that most clearly contrasting on your own to a team premeditating for the last while also attempting to win the Victors League and going toe-to-toe wearing the most spearheading English team conceivably ever before is a miniscule apples/oranges, most clearly no?
MAW, LA Gooner (Owned we ended up a distant 2nd behind Metropolis once the make every effort was to at least sensibly confound for the title once again after that, frankly, a 15th FA cup wouldn’t genuinely have made me feel much more detailed around our season. Once more, standards…)

I bear in mind ago after that once we labelled for an FA Mug win to rescue a desolate season, add a type of wins to a wretched season, assistance absent out on the optimal 4 to Liverpool or coating 8th. Sounds acquainted?  The discrepance is that we were not deluded sufficient to feel we possessed a sweet season.

Bar football is unanimously around paybacks. Depending on how you implemented the previous season, you recover rewarded the next season, and we can unanimously promise that the Victors league is bigger than the Europa league, which in turn is bigger than the Europa seminar league.

That being claimed, FA cup is not bigger than optimal 4, it’s deliberated inferior. That is why it single avails you into UEFA’s inferior occasion. I lug out not price Carabao (Carling Mug). Earlier in the days it was an condone to tinker your fringe players. It was won by the type of Swansea and Tottenham. I position it enjoyable that Mr. Badwolf will most clearly think that FA cup standings above optimal 4. INEOS is aphorism that once reviewing ETH, the FA cup will most clearly be a non determinant. Please make it feasible for that sink in. This cup that you price so much is labelled a non determinant.

Jose Mourinho was sacked in days gone by a Mug final, provided that that Mug was a non determinant.

As Arsenal supporters, we become aware we came up brief, and we are injure, but autocratic…but lug out not affirm capitivating FA cup is much more detailed than what Arteta and his boys purchased, we have worn that shoe in days gone by, and we become aware it’s not much more detailed at unanimously
Kufre, Mien Harcourt, Nigeria

What a methodology to go out
Now that I’ve possessed a day to come down from that remarkable high the ideata of this United suitability being the greatest of the brief message Fergie period hasn’t shrank. There have certainly been polymorphous other sweet galleries, assistance PSG under Ole, and polymorphous other trophies won but to leapt over such opportunities against the nation’s ideal team and win a sizeable trophy sold the context of the season makes this unrivaled in the last 10 years.

10 Hag finally spotted out a strategy his players could stick to, and it wasn’t specifically mystifying. Press high and boldy out of household but single for the initially phase, if you don’t win the ball ago invade shape without arrest. The tight 4-2-4 defensive shape sold Metropolis wearing a wall to enact wearing and two dogged boxers pouncing on anything that made it wearing.

In strike the astonish starter Rashford was formed to rushed in behind but as we’ve witnessed in derbies previous Pedestrian is simply sooner and more powerful than him. Donning that avenue closed down the tinker switched over to Garnacho, sweet remarkable Garnacho. He possessed the £100m Gvardiol on toast the totality game.

The foolhardiness we’ve witnessed over the last couple of months whereby the ball is launched onward at any avenue was gone. The moments to tinker wearing Metropolis’s high line were deliberated and genuinely seldom as both Bruno and Mainoo desperate instead to grasp household and delay for much more detailed opportunities. The counter blows once they came were tragic.

There was talk last week that the single erratic starter for Metropolis would be Doku or Kovacic. Donning this replacement highlighting if Pep was place for wide blows or press resistance. Donning the Croatian prompting Pep tinkered uncolored into the hands of 10 Hag. They purely possessed most clearly no methodology wearing as unanimously the tinker was infatuated centrally. On the rare revelry their attackers spotted liberty a hairless Morrocan battering ram came a thundering on to closed that down and periodically knock them down also.

MORE ON THE MANCHESTER UNITED MESS
👉 Six variables Sir Jim Ratcliffe shouldn’t sack Guy Utd optimal pooch Erik 10 Hag
👉 Sir Jim Ratcliffe harassed for ‘super petty’ FA Mug verdict that escaped Guy Utd personnel ‘enraged’

Every single United player was vibrant. Even the substitutes, which 10 Hag invariably avails notorious, tinkered their guises faultlessly. The discipline and pointer were in stark comparison to the season perfunctory and why I can’t enact on that debt to the manager. After the hefty loss away at Palace the filching a tour supporters stayed to sing and chant for the team till they were compelled to disown by arena personnel. A agglomeration of United players referenced that throughout their brief message match interviews on Saturday. How emboldened they were by the supporters and how that conferred them tenacity. So debt goes to the ideal away stabilize in the universe, you mans is worthy of one hand on the cup.

This speaks to 10 Hags stance as manager. It was always the spanning the INEOS would yearn their super own humans at the nightclub. Nearly unanimously the sizeable humans behind the scenes have currently been proved the door. For the manager to be spared from this he labelled for to lug out to his highest level. He didn’t. This game standoffish 10 Hag has juggled the team poorly most clearly no matter of predicament.

I think INEOS are uncomfortable wearing the level of power and authority he has at nightclub. He principally determines everything ambiguous team openings incorporating coaching schedules and diet regimen which simply doesnt suit wearing the modern-day nightclub that United should become. I think they’ll sack him and recover a promising adviser (conceivably McKenna) that will most clearly be appreciative to simply adviser the team he’s sold.

I assistance 10 Hag but it’s the relevant verdict for the long term future of United. What a methodology to go out yet.
Dave, Manchester

What a methodology to withhold in
Now that ETH has another trophy under his belt, he has come out turning by asking how specifically is he being determined? Have to he tinker cosmetically sweet football that satisfies the media and pundits? How did that resolve for Potter, De Zerbi or Howe? Ange was the beloved of the media at the start of the season but currently he is being mocked as unknowledgeable. Even Arsenal, the current owners of the “joga bonito” crown are still trophy much less after 5 seasons.

Of course we tinkered assistance sh*te for much of the season and won galleries we is worthy of tempted or even thrown away but we also yielded some dazzling entertainment along the methodology. The Liverpool Mug game may well have been the game of the season for entertainment likelihood.

If it’s a results based enterprises, ETH can cite 3 Mug Finals in 2 years wearing 2 trophies, one CL place and one Europe League place. Deserved? Understandably not. Lucky? So what. In the meantime, he has ferried wearing two academy players wearing a nourishing pipeline on the methodology. Isn’t that specifically “United DNA” that Neville et al go on around? Oh, and to protection the alarm system that Alan Shearer inquired as to why did it steal adieu to see MUFC tinker this well, conceivably its provided that it was single the FIFTH time this season ETH could tinker his initially replacement Service Endorses.

So what if he is sacked? ETH can rightly affirm that he will most clearly be snapped up by a optimal nightclub and will most clearly win trophies, vacating MUFC still labeling for to spick-and-expectancy residence and lug out unanimously the things ETH (and Rangnick in days gone by him) says that demands to be implemented.

ETH does not have the personal beauty of a Klopp so never genuinely got the media onside and does at times, come across as exasperated. Yet he wasn’t, and shouldn’t have been hired to be sweet. To fire him currently will most clearly stress that for unanimously that is switched, MUFC sticks approximately the super same.
Adidasmufc (If I was ETH, I would tell the Board to either ago me or sack me and make it feasible for me recover a much more detailed openings)

📣 TO THE COMMENTS! Should Manchester United sack Erik 10 Hag? Join the debate listed below.

Phenomenal Scott
Prefer I picture most United supporters – and Will Ford – I am still reeling from the FA Mug win.

There have been numerous words written, super couple of of them written in days gone by the match (or hastily re-written after it). Yet none that I’ve witnessed have remarked the most staggering minute of the totality match. As well as that was the minute that saw Scotty McTominay not simply enacting but oozing by and retaining household from multiple Metropolis players on the touchline.

It still shows up so bizarre that I may should watch the match once again to dissect it wasn’t a high temperature dream. I genuinely didn’t think the boy possessed it in him. I guess it was simply one of those systematic days.
Badwolf (Posture him 4 additional years, Sir Jim)

FFS, FFP
If our loss retains 10 Hag in his openings, can we dwindle it to 114 for stretch solution?
Paul, Manchester

Shear refinement
How vibrant it was to see 10 Hag posed Alan Shearer ago in his miniscule miniscule box throughout the BBC brief message match interview.
Bagpuss

Tainted babyhoods
It has become super legible to me there are members of the media that lug out not yearn United to succeed once again.
Beefy, United

Juggle a Troyes
As a modify to the FA Mug conversation… but still tangentially related, make it feasible for’s without arrest referral the Metropolis Football Group, and in choosy Troyes – a genuinely minuscule nightclub in France.

They show up to have been made application of as a front for the Metropolis Group to acquire players and personnel, meanwhile slumping down two leagues from Ligue 1 in two years.

As well as currently their former record settling Savio is settling up wearing Guy Metropolis having been shuffled around the Metropolis Group pack over the last couple of years, apparently to help resolve job-related permits or something.

Pretty intense, from what I can tell, and super much in keeping wearing a team wearing 115 polymorphous other collects for worry hanging over them.

Gain!
Badwolf