Manchester United adherents are throwing away persistence by means of £51million midfielder Manuel Ugarte, while Casemiro’s stash proceeds to eruption.
Ugarte came off the seat in United’s 2-2 draw at Tottenham on Saturday mid-day by means of his side 1-0 up.
Thomas Frank’s side equalised 12 minutes after the Uruguayan’s overview, and also 7 minutes afterwards, the Red Devils were 2-1 down.
United did salvage a lug in the 96th minutes thanks to Matthijs de Ligt, yet it was an additional disparaging capability from Ugarte, that was trumped also comfortably by Wilson Odobert for Spurs’ equaliser and also tinkered Richarlison onside for his 91st-minutes header.
Ugarte is a genuinely sub…for Man Utd’s opposition
There’s zero uncertainty that Casemiro is a considerably gourmet volition to Ugarte in Ruben Amorim’s midfield, by means of a defensive-minded midfielder needed for the semblance next off to Bruno Fernandes.
Yet as Ugarte is amassing £120,000 a week, price the club £51m from Paris Saint-Germain, and also Amorim is fixated by means of administering replacements – whether needed or not – he will recur to come off the seat.
At this time, his engagement is deterring Manchester United, not assisting them.
Ugarte is believed to lug resiliences to the core of the park and also aid surf through out arcades. Instead, he’s mostly executing the contrary, acting more favor a genuinely sub for the opposition than the Red Devils.
Odobert slid past him as if he wasn’t there for Spurs’ equaliser, and also Ugarte tipping up for Richarlison’s go-in advance purpose was exceptionally lazy, authenticating a scarcity of focus and also supportive.
Ugarte is purely deterring, not assisting Man Utd
Wear’t merely seize our word for it; the proof is in the treat.
In the Premier League, Manchester United place’t won throughout Ugarte’s time on the pitch, and also their +/- aspirations is -6, by means of a +/- points per 90 minutes of 1.89.
In addition, United have conceded 9 aspirations in unsociable 285 minutes by means of Ugarte on the pitch, while Casemiro owns been on for unsociable 5 of the 18 aspirations conceded in 543 minutes this period.
In specification of aspirations scored, United have netted 12 by means of Casemiro on the pitch and also unsociable three by means of Ugarte.
Peeking at details instances:
- Ugarte came on at Fulham and also 4 minutes afterwards, the Cottagers equalised
- A week afterwards, United earned their first win of the period against Burnley by means of Ugarte an additional replacement
- In the next off video game, Ugarte initiated for the first time in a 3-0 loss against Manchester Municipal township
- Then came 45 minutes against Chelsea, unborn on at half-time by means of his side 2-0 up – layer 2-1, so efficiently 1-0 down by means of Ugarte on and also Casemiro off (albeit due to a red card)
- Five minutes in the 2-0 win over Sunderland believed it was 0-0 by means of Ugarte on
- Away to Liverpool, he came on at 1-0 up and also the video game finished 2-1
- A 1-1 draw at house to Brighton was abided by means of by a 2-2 draw against Nottingham Woodland – a video game in which Ugarte didn’t even come off the seat.
- And also currently, we’re at the 2-2 draw at Spurs, perhaps the lowest time of Ugarte’s United job so much
We place’t even remarked that Ugarte initiated in the Carabao Mug at Grimsby Vicinity and also was addicted at half-time by means of Amorim’s males 2-0 down.
Amorim’s replacements have price Man Utd
Casemiro’s video game by numbers vs. Spurs:
100% long enact honesty
100% cross honesty
83% enact honesty
56% ground duels won
44 touches
5 enacts into the final finally
5 sphere recuperations
4 takes on
4 clearancesHaving a luminescent period. 👏 image.twitter.com/TjWuEIGqsl
— Statman Dave (@StatmanDave) November 8, 2025
There’s still time for Ugarte to come extravagant. After all, Casemiro was earth subdivision, then abysmal, and also is currently one of United’s most invaluable players – surely Amorim’s greatest profitability story in the squad.
Ugarte is more of a hindrance than a aid defensively, and also is purely marginal going forward, so it’s most most certainly time for Amorim to as essential trial a collaboration of Kobbie Mainoo and also Fernandes if he doesn’t pine to demographic Casemiro on for the complete 90 minutes.
Replacing Casemiro off appears to be a behavior for Amorim. Prohibitive replacements are unborn to be one of his strongest ‘services’.
The Portuguese boss ceaselessly fluctuations his centre-recommends mid-video game, bringing off Harry Maguire against Spurs, for instance, regardless of him playing nicely.
